Friday, February 19, 2010

Removing the Human from Humanity

This is from the Huffington Post:

The New York Times had a very interesting Op-Ed Friday, which took an unusual approach to the concern that factory farms are inhumane. Adam Shriver, a doctoral student in the philosophy-neuroscience-psychology program at Washington University, makes the argument that the key to raising more humane meat isn't changing the methods by which they are raised, but to genetically engineer them so they feel less pain from their conditions.
We are most likely stuck with factory farms, given that they produce most of the beef and pork Americans consume. But it is still possible to reduce the animals' discomfort -- through neuroscience. Recent advances suggest it may soon be possible to genetically engineer livestock so that they suffer much less.

Shriver's Op-Ed raises several questions. Is the most appalling part about factory farms -- where animals are fed unnatural diets, live in filthy conditions, and are subject to preemptive antibiotics -- is that they are suffering? Confined Animal Feedlot Operations are responsible for huge amounts of waste, which threaten groundwater, air quality and can pose public health risks. Meat production is also responsible for more greenhouse gas emissions than all modes of transportation. Would genetically engineering animals so they suffer less help factory farms flourish, without addressing the environmental risks they pose? Is genetically engineering our food supply to appeal to a moral conscience about suffering appropriate?

____________________

Forgive the rant ahead:

Let me tell you who a question like this is aimed at, people like Anthony Bourdain, like the people on Food Network, like Foodies or anyone else who wants to be insulated from the fact that eating animals is blantently ONE word. MURDER. If you want to feel good about eating food, guess what, raise it yourself OR buy from vendors or farmers that you know, but DO not try to get me to sign on to a idiotic idea like this. This question keeps appearing, so my faithful readers, I see it coming. Monsanto will try to do it within the next 15 years or Cargill or Smithfield Farms but of course, if that happens HOW are they going to prove it to us? By slaughtering an animal in public so that we can see that we've removed ALL traces of pain? What about the fear? Can you remove that too? Then what about our consciousness in dealing with the fact that these are LIVING, BREATHING, SENTIENT beings. This idea disgusts me and there is NO higher level of distaste that I can issue towards it.

No comments: